A blog by Luke Akehurst about politics, elections, and the Labour Party - With subtitles for the Hard of Left. Just for the record: all the views expressed here are entirely personal and do not necessarily represent the positions of any organisations I am a member of.

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

Purnell's speech

I got an email yesterday from a friend whose politics are broadly Compass-ite saying "Have you read this Luke? Thought you’d like it - it’s a brilliant critique of Cameron – by far the best I've read from a cabinet minister recently"

It linked to this speech by James Purnell last week.

It deserves reading.

24 Comments:

Blogger Jack Ray said...

haha, so he's basically accusing Cameron of being Tony Blair circa 1997 :D

3:55 pm, June 25, 2008

 
Blogger Miller 2.0 said...

I think it's a brilliant analysis.

I also like some of Purnell's welfare reform ideas.

But his broader politics can go to hell.

5:09 pm, June 25, 2008

 
Anonymous brownite said...

But his broader politics can go to hell.

Real mature attitude there Miller 2.0

Somehow I don't think Mr Purnell gives a damn what you think.

And you say you're a supporter of the Labour party! Sheesh!

When was the last time you said or did anything supportive of the government?

Time you stopped acting like a propagandist for the opposition.

5:13 pm, June 25, 2008

 
Blogger Merseymike said...

Yes, good speech - I think that the Tories honeymoon should they become the Government would be very short indeed, since they don't really have any solutions.

The problem is, neither do the government. As far as welfare reform is concerned, Frank Field is someone who has a couple of basics absolutely right.

First, that we tax the poor far too heavily and at a far too low entry level

Second, that means testing is a mistake since it has disincentives built into it.

I'm not convinced that Purnell''s ideas deal with either of those issues and they are vital.

6:30 pm, June 25, 2008

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Luke praising a piece that talks about intellectual tradition - wonders will never cease.

Isn't this the sort of thing that appeals to those dreadful Guardian reading types.

10:51 am, June 26, 2008

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great expectations.

But then I read first ten pars and realised I was into Akehurst value-added which roughly equates to yah-boo lite.

Cameron confused about what he stands for.

Is that so? Well, I never.

The moat lodged into Purnell's brain which just seems to slip his memory is that Cameron is 20 points ahead in the polls.

If I were you I wouldn't be worrying too much about Cameron at this stage.

There's a brooding, socially inadequate, cack-handed clown sitting at the cabinet table with him every week called Brown.

What to do about Brown, or is Banquo, must be the sole topic of conversation among Labour Party members but he never gets a mention on this blog.

Funny that.

4:41 pm, June 26, 2008

 
Blogger Miller 2.0 said...

"When was the last time you said or did anything supportive of the government?"

Probably on Monday.

I think loyalty to values and loyalty to the electorate are both more important than loyalty to party, at least, as long as you're not a member of the Government.

I definitely don't believe that membership of a political party removes your right to publicly criticise it or argue for it to change.

I think it's time that the top of our party was more loyal to the thousands which make up the bottom of it.

"Somehow I don't think Mr Purnell gives a damn what you think."

That's precisely what's wrong with 'his broader politics'. Loyalty goes both ways.

Anyway... when Purnell makes some public statements in favour of party policy such as rail nationalisation and the 4th option, I'll be in a better mind to be a bit more compliant. ;o)

5:18 pm, June 26, 2008

 
Blogger Miller 2.0 said...

"Cameron confused about what he stands for.

Is that so? Well, I never."

I think that's unfair.

Purnell seems to get the strategy that Cameron is putting in place; lurching the tory narrative (but I note, not the policy, because there is none) from left to right.

I wish I could have put the same points as succinctly, to be honest.

5:27 pm, June 26, 2008

 
Blogger Jack Ray said...

so, why do you think it's such brilliant analysis then? I mean he could take any Tory policy document from 1994 onwards, swap the political orientation and it'd read exactly the same. "the opposition is stealing our political ground, they don't stand for anything, just the unprincipled grasp for power". It could just as easily describe the politics of both front benches.

Oh, and surprise, public school education Oxonian doesn't think that Cameron's background is a problem shocker!

5:39 pm, June 26, 2008

 
Anonymous brownite said...

Environment policy! That's really gonna win us the next election.

How about supporting the government on issues the public are actually in favour of. Like 42 days. Or do you only believe in loyalty to the electorate when it suits you?

It's time to get behind the government and our great leader. He may not be perfect, but he's better than Cameron.

Maybe Miller 2.0 is a closet Tory?

5:46 pm, June 26, 2008

 
Anonymous Rich said...

LOL, great leader you are having a laugh. The economy is falling around our ears because of Brown and you really think the voters are going to support you.

A recent classic the government recently passed the Decent Homes Act which enforces home standards for local authorities. Yet the same government also sets the rents local authorities can charge for their properties. So big is the gap that most housing associations and local authorities are now running unviable businesses. They can't make money to reinvest in their housing stock because the rents are not even covering the repairs.

This government legislates without even considering the consequences,

7:46 pm, June 26, 2008

 
Blogger Reversepsychology said...

brownite:

As it stands - only an act from God will surfice to win New Labour the next election. And Gordon Brown is certainly not the almighty.

The British electorate have lost confidence in this current government because of certain policies, in which they seem determined to persue, so where is the harm in openly debating such issues?
A bunker mentality is detremental to this Country at large. Or is it that in your own self righteous opinion, Gordon Brown is more important than that?

The last thing the Labour party need right now, is to go into self imposed meltdown, because of an inabiltiy to listen and debate, whilst emiting a breath taking arrogance in ignoring anybodys opinions other than their own, for no better reason, than self preservation.
That is not democracy.

7:50 pm, June 26, 2008

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

And now what do you think of Purenll after his speech to the government about welfare, last year the Tories said benefits should be time limited Purnell said see the Tories hate the disabled, now Purnell says yes benefits must be time limited IB has to go and all benefits must be means tested. good old Purnell a Tory through and through

12:53 pm, July 19, 2008

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

tibia money tibia gold tibia item runescape money runescape gold tibia money tibia gold runescape gold runescape powerleveling runescape accounts tibia gold tibia money runescape money runescape gp buy runescape gold tibia gold tibia item buy runescape money runescape gold runescape items tibia money tibia gold runescape power leveling

1:20 am, August 07, 2008

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Game is stillcheap wow gold using the world of warcraft goldoriginal series for buy wow goldbasic components:buy wow gold put her daughterdofus kamas into a princesskamas dofus for the purposeFinal Fantasy XI gil of cultivation.ffxi gil This stage is lotr golddivided into days for theflyff penya sector, buy flyff goldGhosts, fairy Maple Story Mesoscircles, stars Maple Story mesothe spirit world and EverQuest 2 goldthe people ofeq2 plat these fiveRunescape gold world community.Runescape money Sector to sectorRunescape Money five peopleRunescape Power leveling as the centerRunescape Gold maintained a balance,ffxi gil however, new dofus kamasforces trying kamas dofusto disrupt dofus kamasthis balance, the mostkamas dofus symbolic is dofus kamasto become a princesskamas dofus alternate dead. Game players, is to become dofus kamasan alternate Finally, the 10-year-old kamas dofusgirl's father, the guardian and child-rearing.

2:17 am, March 24, 2009

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The girls lost hair straightenerstheir memory,GHD I do not knowreplica handbags that he ischi hair straighteners the alternate wholesale handbagsprincess, nor do replica designer handbagsI knowkamas dofus
their replica watchlives dofus kamas
are being swiss replica watchespeep the new forces.replica rolex watches Players as a father,puma shoes is to cultivatenike shoes the child womens clothesinto the princessed hardy clothing excellent. So far the replica handbagsworld series replica watchesgames are modeled Designer clothingon medieval Europe. Designer replica handbagsAnd this made Wholesale jewelryby the five Replica rolex watchesworld, so that replica handbagthere is Replica Handbagstelevision, network,Replica Watches mobile phone and otherreplica designer handbags modern elements, Coach Handbagsand Monster, goblin,Gucci Handbags such as fantasyRolex Watches elements. the works of previous series do not feel.

2:17 am, March 24, 2009

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Beijing Tong wow gold pricesJi entertainmentwow gold hacks "Princess Maker wow gold guides4", the agent will cheap wow gold eucontinue to "Princesswow gold game Maker 5" Simplifiedmake wow gold Chinese wow gold shopversion of thewow europe gold issue.wow fishingInternationally well-knownwow gold trade game publisherswow gold making THQ Inc.wow gold online announced wow hacksthat Gas Poweredpaladin wow Games has gold in wowdeveloped real-timevery cheap wow gold strategy wow gold sellersci-fi masterpiece, "Supremebuy gold for wow Commander wow gold exchange(Supreme Commander)" cheap gold for wowhas completedselling wow gold all development workwow gold guide and will be wow gold priceFebruary 20, 2007buy cheap wow gold listed in the buy guild wars goldglobal market. As a successionsell wow gold of well-known RTS cheapest wow goldgame "Total Annihilation (Total Annihilation)"

2:17 am, March 24, 2009

 
Anonymous jackier said...

Children and teenagers who face the greatest risk of nutritional deficiencies tend to use vitamin and mineral supplements the least, researchers reported Monday.Among 10,828 US children ages 2 to 17 years old who participated in the 1999 to 2004 United States National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, roughly 34 percent had used vitamin and mineral supplements in the past month."We hypothesized," Dr. Ulfat Shaikh told Reuters Health, "that children who had poor diets (low vegetable intake, low milk intake, high fat intake, low fiber intake), world of warcraft goldwow power levelcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingbuy wow goldEverQuest 2 goldeq2 platfaced food insecurity, had less physical activity and poor access to health care, would use such supplements more.""What we found was for the most part the opposite of what we expected,"cheap ffxi gilffxi gilfinal fantasy gilMaple Story Mesosmaple story accountmaplestory MesosLOTRO Goldlord of the rings goldLOTR Golddofus kamaskamas dofus said Shaikh from University of California Davis School of Medicine, Sacramento."Other than children who were underweight (we did expect these children to use more vitamin and mineral supplements and found this to be true from the data), runescape goldrunescape powerlevelingrunescape moneyArchLord goldarchlord powerlevelingbuy ArchLord goldflyff penyabuy flyff goldflyff moneyWarhammer goldbuy warhammer goldchildren who used vitamin and mineral supplements were for the most part healthier, had more nutritious diets, greater physical activity, lower sedentary activity, lower obesity, lower food insecurity and better health care access,"

1:30 am, May 05, 2009

 
Anonymous jackier said...

Yim's group looked for a link between placental corticotropin-releasing hormone (pCRH) and postpartum depression. The researchers took blood samples from 100 pregnant women at various stages during their pregnancy and tested for levels of pCRH.They also assessed the women for signs of depression during pregnancy and about eight weeks, on average, after delivery.In all, 16 women developed postpartum depression. world of warcraft goldbuy wow goldcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingeverquest 2 goldeq2 platIn each case, the women had had high levels of pCRH at 25 weeks into their pregnancies, the study found.final fantasy 11 cheap gilbuy ffxi gilffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosmaplestory mesoThe blood test, which was found to have a high degree of both specificity and sensitivity, could identify about 75 percent of women who would develop postpartum depression, Yim's team found. lotro goldlotr goldlord of the ring goldrunescape goldrunescape moneyrunescape itemsThe test misclassified about 25 percent of the women.When the blood test was combined with assessing symptoms of depression during pregnancy, Yim noted, it was even more predictive of postpartum depression.dofus kamaskamas dofuswarhammer goldbuy warhammer goldCheap warhammer goldflyff penyabuy flyff goldflyff moneyIf the findings can be replicated, then testing the level of this hormone might become standard care, Yim said."eve iskeve online iskarchlord goldbuy archlord goldPostpartum depression affects so many women that it would be great to have something that would help to identify being at risk early on, and perhaps develop strategies to prevent it," she said.

1:36 am, May 05, 2009

 
Blogger KM said...

手島優大堀恵杉原杏璃川奈栞ロリエロ10代エロ華彩なな次原かな風間ゆみ風間ゆみ立花里子鮎川なおAV女優フェラフェラチオフェラフェラフェラフェラフェラフェラチオフェラチオフェラチオエッチエッチエッチエッチエッチアダルト無料アダルトアダルト無料アダルトアダルトアダルト動画エロアニメえろアニメ堤さやか及川奈央小林ひとみ長瀬愛グラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアアイドルグラビアヌード

6:14 am, December 11, 2009

 
Blogger KM said...

眞鍋かをり高部知子長谷川ちひろ有川知里杉原杏璃西田麻衣松金洋子森下悠里滝沢乃南篠崎愛桜田さくら真木よう子次原かな浅野光ほしのあき原幹恵南結衣花井美理中川杏奈河中あい池田夏希中村静香岡本果奈美秦みずほ三井麻由磯山さやか松岡音々前田敦子石原さとみ釈由美子浜田翔子浜田コウ黒田知永子上戸彩加護亜依サイン競馬南明奈優木まおみ川村ゆきえ佐々木希スザンヌ山本梓ゴランジェリー岡崎美女飯島愛樹まり子近親相姦朝岡実嶺高樹マリアあいだもも夏目ナナ紅音ほたる無料版無料版無料版

6:14 am, December 11, 2009

 
Blogger KM said...

アダルト無料アダルトアダルト無料アダルトアダルトアダルト動画エロアニメえろアニメエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログ

6:14 am, December 11, 2009

 
Blogger KM said...

エログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログ

6:14 am, December 11, 2009

 
Blogger KM said...

エログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログエログアダルトサイン競馬無修正

6:15 am, December 11, 2009

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

 
Free Hit Counters
OfficeDepot Discount